When I first read Amy Ellis Nutt's articles, I was fascinated by the psychological aspects that she brings to light in her writing. The Accidental Artist is a story about a man named Jon Sarkin who suffered a stroke, and whose life was forever changed because of it.
A simple game of golf lead to the psychological phenomenon that doctors still have no explanation for. Most people who suffer from a stroke like Sarkin's end up losing their sense of identity from before the accident. Jon Sarkin remembers perfectly who he was, which only makes his condition worse. Sarkin now has the uncontrollable urge to create masterful works of art, changing doodles on the margin of a page into beautifully painted canvases, worth however much someone is willing to offer.
Nutt's rendition of this story is one of lost dreams and sad realities, but also one of beauty. Personal interviews with every person who took part in Sarkin's story brought a new light and feeling to the article. Nutt was also able to tie in stories of the interviewee's pasts, which made the story more interesting to read.
The way in which the article was written and presented made it not only interesting, but also fun to read. Back stories and subtle jokes makes the reader want to keep reading.
I do suggest that Mrs. Nutt not write nine chapter articles, however interesting. It felt like I was reading a short story, or a small novel rather then a newspaper article. I understand that there was a lot of psychological detail that needed to be put into the story, but I feel like it did not have to take the reader and hour and a half to read it.
Friday, January 28, 2011
Friday, January 21, 2011
Issue 6 Critique
On The Front Line - by Katie Guyot
Positives - Talking about the lives of army parents and students is interesting and a good topic to focus on, especially with the current situation in the Middle East. When Katie wrote about the different kids and the way that their parents being gone has affected their lives, I felt like I really understood and was able to be empathetic, even though neither of my parents are in the armed forces. Different stories bring up different emotions in readers, and I think this story did a really good job of that. Being able to interview one of the parents really added a little something.
Negatives - If there had been a picture of one of the kids and their parents, I think that would have really added to the story. Actually seeing that kind of thing really hits home. Also, the way that the story was written seemed like it told a story, then abruptly stopped to start the next story. When reading it, I felt like it was very "stop-and-go." Having more of a flow makes the story easier to read.
Positives - Talking about the lives of army parents and students is interesting and a good topic to focus on, especially with the current situation in the Middle East. When Katie wrote about the different kids and the way that their parents being gone has affected their lives, I felt like I really understood and was able to be empathetic, even though neither of my parents are in the armed forces. Different stories bring up different emotions in readers, and I think this story did a really good job of that. Being able to interview one of the parents really added a little something.
Negatives - If there had been a picture of one of the kids and their parents, I think that would have really added to the story. Actually seeing that kind of thing really hits home. Also, the way that the story was written seemed like it told a story, then abruptly stopped to start the next story. When reading it, I felt like it was very "stop-and-go." Having more of a flow makes the story easier to read.
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
Reaction to SPLC Article
Editor of Ind. student paper asks school officials to return confiscated issues
Opinion Privilege - because the students were simply stating their opinion.
Fair Comment and Criticism - because the students should have been able to criticize their superiors.
I found this article rather interesting based on its portrayal of the people taking part in it. The student editor was percieved as innocent, but determined to make something happen. The board of education, however, was shown to have their minds made up before they even started the meeting. Some of the "higher up" officials commented on the issue, but they didn't seem to be to concerned with it, or have any idea of what to do about it. The actual article that caused the problem was simply a comentary on the resignation of the school's losing football team's coach. The Scout simply stated that the football team needed a change, and they weren't complaining about the resignation of their old coach. They never flat out celebrated it, but they never said anything bad about him other than the fact that they had had three losing seasons with him.
Opinion Privilege - because the students were simply stating their opinion.
Fair Comment and Criticism - because the students should have been able to criticize their superiors.
I found this article rather interesting based on its portrayal of the people taking part in it. The student editor was percieved as innocent, but determined to make something happen. The board of education, however, was shown to have their minds made up before they even started the meeting. Some of the "higher up" officials commented on the issue, but they didn't seem to be to concerned with it, or have any idea of what to do about it. The actual article that caused the problem was simply a comentary on the resignation of the school's losing football team's coach. The Scout simply stated that the football team needed a change, and they weren't complaining about the resignation of their old coach. They never flat out celebrated it, but they never said anything bad about him other than the fact that they had had three losing seasons with him.
Friday, January 14, 2011
Current Events - January 13, 2011
Advocate - Tuscon shooting not driven by politics
This CE displays the following Elements of Newsworthiness:
Ever since the actual shooting occurred on Jan. 8, 2011, many people have been speculating that Jared Loughner, the shooter, was tempted and eventually forced, indirectly, to kill by the actions of prominent political figures. Some blame Sarah Palin, the tea party, and Obamacare opponents for their actions and claim that they led Loughner to kill, when in actuality he was mentally unstable.
Inform - Kassie Liebsch pleads guilty to wire fraud, faces up to 20 years in prison in KU ticket scandal
This CE displays the following Elements of Newsworthiness:
Entertain - 2010 Obsessions
This CE displays the following Elements of Newsworthiness:
- Conflict - because many people believe that Sarah Palin's actions led Loughner to kill people, and others don't.
- Impact - because public icons are being blamed for the death of many people.
- Drama - The president doesn't usually hold a ceremony to honor those who died if someone got into a car wreck and died. There was a spectacle.
- Oddity - because it was reported that Loughner seemed to live in his own world, a sort of "conscious dreaming," and his writings contained odd numerology. He was a schizophrenic.
Ever since the actual shooting occurred on Jan. 8, 2011, many people have been speculating that Jared Loughner, the shooter, was tempted and eventually forced, indirectly, to kill by the actions of prominent political figures. Some blame Sarah Palin, the tea party, and Obamacare opponents for their actions and claim that they led Loughner to kill, when in actuality he was mentally unstable.
Inform - Kassie Liebsch pleads guilty to wire fraud, faces up to 20 years in prison in KU ticket scandal
This CE displays the following Elements of Newsworthiness:
- Proximity - KU is in Lawrence.
- Drama - Many people lost their jobs because of the ticket scandal.
- Impact - The scandal impacted many people and those people want to know who is responsible for their loss of money and tickets.
Kassie Liebsch, 27, pleaded guilty on Jan. 13 to a scheme to steal around $2 million of athletic tickets and evade taxes on the transactions. She was originally given a sentence of 20 years, but her intended cooperation with the prosecution to help identify and prosecute others who benefited from the fraud could lead to a reduced sentence.
Persuade - Review: 127 Hours
- Audience - because the way that Eric Melin (reporter) describes the movie, any body remotely interested in cinema or thrill-seeking for that matter would be persuaded to go see it.
- Drama - The movie itself is drama, and Melin does a good job of conveying that in his story.
- Prominence - This is a true story, and the way that it is portrayed in Melin's story and (apparently) in the movie make the watcher realize the importance and magnitude of the struggle that the character goes through.
Aron Ralston is a thrill-seeker and a dare-devil, but one mistake and he's fighting for his life. Danny Boyle, director, did a fantastic job of mismatching the music and scenes in a way that fit a 20-year-old's personality. Some movie goers were so affected by the film that they actually fainted in the theater.
- Timelessness - This article is just a review of the entire 2010 year
- Drama - This past year has been nothing but drama! There is nothing on this list that people haven't heard and talked about
- Audience - This article was mostly written for people who enjoy the entertainment industry, and people who are interested only in politics would probably not even bother giving this article a second glance.
Wednesday, January 5, 2011
Five Freedoms
The five freedoms that were established in the First Amendment were as follows:
1. Speech
2. Press
3. Religion
4. Assembly
5. Petition
Out of the five freedoms, the one that affects my life the most would probably freedom of press. Students being given the right to write what they want in a school newspaper has made this freedom apparent in my life.
Speech, press, religion, assembly, and petition were all grouped into the First Amendment because they were the foundation of the following amendments, and they made it possible for the others to be successful.
1. Speech
2. Press
3. Religion
4. Assembly
5. Petition
Out of the five freedoms, the one that affects my life the most would probably freedom of press. Students being given the right to write what they want in a school newspaper has made this freedom apparent in my life.
Speech, press, religion, assembly, and petition were all grouped into the First Amendment because they were the foundation of the following amendments, and they made it possible for the others to be successful.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)