On The Front Line - by Katie Guyot
Positives - Talking about the lives of army parents and students is interesting and a good topic to focus on, especially with the current situation in the Middle East. When Katie wrote about the different kids and the way that their parents being gone has affected their lives, I felt like I really understood and was able to be empathetic, even though neither of my parents are in the armed forces. Different stories bring up different emotions in readers, and I think this story did a really good job of that. Being able to interview one of the parents really added a little something.
Negatives - If there had been a picture of one of the kids and their parents, I think that would have really added to the story. Actually seeing that kind of thing really hits home. Also, the way that the story was written seemed like it told a story, then abruptly stopped to start the next story. When reading it, I felt like it was very "stop-and-go." Having more of a flow makes the story easier to read.
For short reading, like on the web, use bullet points to make it easier to skim your ideas.
ReplyDeleteAlso, when you critique the paper look for positives and negatives throughout the whole issue, not just one story.
ReplyDelete