Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Issue 7 Critique

Positives - The center spread of this last issue had me splitting at my sides. Ryan's face plastered everywhere was hilarious.  I, personally, am one for sarcasm, and the little side comment "Note: quiz results not guaranteed" made me laugh.  The website is also really cool because I was able to read some of the main stories before the newspaper came out.  The designs on pages 2, 5, and 11 were all very appealing and made me want to read the stories.
Negatives - The "Do's and Don'ts of Valentine's Day" was kind of sexist in my opinion.  The advice for the guys was all about how to make your girlfriend happy and what types of gifts to get, while the girls advice was to keep in mind that "it's the thought that counts" rather then helping girls with gift ideas.  It made it seem like Valentine's Day is a day when a boy buys a girl chocolates, but the girl doesn't really have to do anything in return.  One downside to the website is that it isn't updated regularly.  I'm still seeing "Bird'sWord" from several issues ago.  Also, it seems like the same students and teachers are being interviewed.  I know that Free Press has a rule where they don't interview their friends and try to step outside their social circle, but sometimes your friends have a strong opinion on something, and quoting them in a story would work better.  At Southwest, when I was on newspaper, we had a list of the entire student body split up by grades.  When we needed to interview someone, we closed our eyes and ran our finger down the list.  Whatever name we landed on was the person we would interview.  I think this might be a good thing for Free Press to try.  In "Singing Out Loud" I think it would have been better to get a current picture, maybe of groups at a practice from this year, rather then last.  On the website also, the photos of the week are from football season...

No comments:

Post a Comment